"Hello. We'd like to share an encouraging thought with you from the Bible for our new neighbors."
"Thank you. Go away. Goodbye."
I closed the door. They got back in their car, sat for a bit, then drove off. I was nice enough to wait until they were out of sight before taping the other "No preaching" sticker from Ring of Fire Enterprises to the inside of the front storm door. (There was already one on the back door.)